Wednesday, February 15, 2017

Why I protest

“When the artist is alive in any person, whatever his kind of work may be, he becomes an inventive, searching, daring, self-expressive creature. He becomes interesting to other people. He disturbs, upsets, enlightens, and opens ways for better understanding. Where those who are not artists are trying to close the book, he opens it and shows there are still more pages possible.” – Robert Henri

Most of my art is “pretty.” I like showing people the miracles I see in the natural world. I think that is because at heart, I am an optimist. I choose to turn my face to the light. Even in troubling times, I try very hard to keep my chin up. 

It’s been hard lately. I look at my country, which I love so much, and I see so much discord and hate and fear. So much failure to communicate. I believe that if we do not figure out how to start listening and talking to each other, our country is doomed. And I believe that art is an essential part of communication.

I am a complex person, and there is more to me than my beautiful fiber art and photographs. I know who I am. I have strong emotions and strong opinions. And I am not afraid to speak them. This, apparently, makes some people angry. Very, very angry.

When I posted the Call for Entries for “Threads of Resistance” on social media, and each time I posted updates, I got nasty comments. Some contained offensive names for our former president, mocked Hillary Clinton, and dripped with vitriol, with tones by turn scornful, angry and jeering. Sadly, the long presidential campaign season has hardened me to this kind of language. It is the language of Donald J. Trump, now made acceptable, and echoed by millions of Americans. I expected it. Im used to it by now. 

What did baffle me were the comments that basically told me that my role was to provide eye candy and keep my mouth shut. That I was using my “platform” to undermine the government,” that quilting and politics should never mix, that I was making people sad or disturbing the sanctity of the peaceful quilting community. Or that I was being unpatriotic by not completely supporting the president or “giving him a chance.”

Ummmmm.... what? Here are my thoughts on those points:

1. It is not my job – or the job of any artist – to make pretty pictures that make people happy. Sure, I do that most of the time. But I also don’t put my head in the sand and ignore what is happening around me. I make art about what moves me emotionally, what I am passionate about. Yes, I keep my face to the light. But I will not ignore the creeping shadows.

2. Quilts can be art. Throughout history, artists have used their work to protest. For a quick look at some protest art, try googling "protest art" images. Women, who have throughout history had fewer options available to them, have long protested in their needlework – embroidery and quilts. One could argue that Betsy Rossfirst American flag was protest art. Women have made quilts in the cause of many protests: temperance, women's suffrage, reproductive rights, anti-war, and civil rights.  
 
 3. Telling me to keep my mouth shut and my opinions to myself is flat-out intimidation, and it is wrong. It is especially wrong if it is said in a rude or threatening way. It would be very easy for me to keep my mouth shut right now. I am taking a risk, and I know it. I am willing to do it because I think the risks – to me, to my children, to Americans, and to democracy itself – of not speaking out are greater. If I dont speak out, I am complicit.

First they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Socialist.

Then they came for the Trade Unionists, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Trade Unionist.
Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.
– Martin Niemoller (1892-1984), pastor and outspoken public foe of Adolf Hitler

4. Protest is patriotic. Theodore Roosevelt once said, “Patriotism means to stand by the country. It does not mean to stand by the president or any other public official.If Americans had not chosen to protest, we would still be a colony of England. We would still have slavery. People of color and women would not have the right to vote. “Coloredswould still be using separate drinking fountains and bathrooms and going to separate schools. People would not have the right to marry the people they love, regardless of gender. The list goes on and on...

I am not advocating a violent overturn of the government. (One of the commenters suggested that I sided with Madonna, who said that she thought about blowing up the White House. I do not; I think her remark was wrong.) I am merely exercising my right to speak freely through art – a right given to me as an American under the First Amendment:


“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”


When things that are important to me come under fire – truth, a free press, religious freedom and separation of church and state, the influence of hate groups in government, to name a few – I will always speak up. 


• • • • • 

At its core, art is communication. It is an artist’s way of saying, “Look at this! Please… see what I see!” Sometimes that is beauty. Sometimes it is pain. Sometimes it is a viewpoint. It is my hope that the fiber art in the “Threads of Resistance” exhibition will make people think, make people feel, make people consider another perspective. 

For more information on “Threads of Resistance,” please go to the Threads of Resistance website

43 comments:

  1. Dear Susan, I quoted Mr Niemoller to my bee recently also and they all looked at me like I was totally out of my mind. Well in France, my family lived under Hitler and they saw that IT DID happen. One after the others, they were gone and many were not seen again. My little village didn't really recover for a VERY long time. Some families to this day are still not trusted as they brought so much pain to others. Lucky the Americans came to stop it all in time, though! And even though life was so hard in the after-war years, I was able to grow up free.
    And by the way, quilters have always taken causes: Voting rights, anti-slavery, various presidential campaigns, various cancers, HIV (I still remember the quilts on the grass on the Mall in DC-this was so powerful!) 9-11, and probably many others. I would send those "so-called" quilters to their quilt history books and learn how quilters in the past and now are taking up important causes. Nothing new there. Thank you Susan for speaking up. We need many more people like you especially where it would count the most: Congress!. Annick H.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Oh. My. Gosh. Susan! So very well said! Thank you, thank you! Especially "If I don't speak out, I am complicit".

    maggie

    ReplyDelete
  3. You have expressed yourself very well. I stand with you and the other brave artists who feel compelled to take a stand. Now more than ever.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Well said. Art is a means of communication whether it be sad, happy, fearful, resentful or as a means of solitary. Continue to do what you do so well but through your photography, quilting or writing. Your message is not only important, it is vital. ( just our of curiosity, how many of those mean-spirited remarks are made by men? I have had quite a few directed toward me and they have all come from men.)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Dear Susan, I have learned your language, but it is not perfect, so I only want to say: What you do, is so important! Elisabeth

    ReplyDelete
  6. I am so grateful you are speaking out. We have all been under attack when in our hearts we know each of us is following our soul's guidance in ways that they cannot understand. I cry for those who remain in denial practicing deflection and continual distraction. Many of us fought back the darkness we felt coming long before the election with a dreaded knowing and now each of us in her own way is bringing in the light through any crack we can find,chisel,or create. Keep listening to your heart and feel the angels surrounding you with guidance and protection from the shadows, slings and arrows.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thank you so much! I was so inspired by your posts, personally, affirmed and encouraged. If art does not stir us why are we doing it? Thank you, thank you. I have long admired your art and your generosity with your art, and now I admire your honesty and courage.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thank you for a great blog post. I made a quilt to carry at the women's march and I had many people telling me that quilts and politics shouldn't mix. I especially love how you phrased points 1 and 3. The kind of intimidation and threats I have seen in regards to artists recently speaking out is just unjustifiable to me. Anyway, I applaud you! Also, have you seen Lisa Congdon's post? http://lisacongdon.com/blog/2017/02/on-politics/

    ReplyDelete
  9. Day by day it becomes more surreal and threatening. It is not just our right to speak up, but our duty—with our words and actions and our art. In solidarity...

    ReplyDelete
  10. Beautiful and I am so with you. I have done some political art in the past, but this time it is so much more important to me to express what I am feeling. I am older than dirt and I have lived through bad times in the past, but this seems so different. Thank you for this.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Well said! Thank you for taking a brave stand.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thank you and well said. I agree with you completely.
    How dare anyone suggest that you don't have a right to express yourself!! You and the many who marched the day after inauguration have my admiration and thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  13. P.S. Nevertheless she persisted!!! Right on.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Susan, I couldn't agree with you more!! Thank you for posting this! I have shared it on my Facebook page. I wish I was in a position to enter your show, but unfortunately I'm in the middle of moving and my art supplies are packed up; maybe you could make "Threads of Resistance" a yearly show over the next four years while Trump is in office? Just a thought!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Well said, keep speaking out- with your words and your art!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Very well said! As i read through the posts so far, each one spoke to me in the language i understand as a woman, an artist and a curious person who works in fabric and color, mostly! Susan keep speaking out- with your words and your art! And so shall we!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Your words are an inspiration to me. Keep speaking them--because they matter.

    ReplyDelete
  18. One of my very first quilts was made for The Ribbon Project which took place on August 4, 1985. The "ribbon" was composed of tens of thousands of hand made quilted banners illustrating the theme ``What I cannot bear to think of as lost forever in nuclear war''. It encircled the Pentagon and was stretched over ten miles. We must continue to voice our opinions through our art. Thank you, Susan, for voicing your opinion. Peace.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Very well said Susan! Art is a way of making your voice heard. I do know that I have become involved in different things since this election. We must not sit on the sidelines and let what will be happen. We do need to speak up. Again, thanks for your words.

    ReplyDelete
  20. We can only account for ourselves... I try to live by and taught my children to live by these words I heard - source not remembered - Is it illegal, is it illicit, is it immoral when faced with choices. Then as they left the house Make good choices was the last phrase they heard. I believe in many things but these are the foundation of how I want to be. Speaking out on issues has caused me some grief in live. But I wouldn't change it. Freedom of choice can can be a dilemma - a double edge sword. It can give the choice for people to do and believe in immoral, illegal and illicit things. I am Canadian so I technically am not involved in your political situation but it has caused a lot of disscusion in our country too. Maybe we need to look at our world and test it to my words to my kids. It would make the world a happier place.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Well said! Not American but sad & worried by what is happening - stay strong, the world needs more people like you.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Bravo. I am grateful to you and to everyone else who has spoken out and continues to speak out. I've gotten some blow back myself, and have lost all sorts of followers on IG and some "friends" on FB. Most recently and for the first time, I actually started to feel some real fear, and really had to think long and hard over whether or not I should continue to express myself publicly or just go quiet. Ultimately I decided that yes, I will keep expressing myself. I will keep speaking out. The fate of our country, its people and our values is simply too important to stand by and watch in silence, as all we honor and hold dear is eroded and dismantled before our very eyes.

    And on a side note... I've never been a Madonna fan, but in her defense when I saw her speak at the March in Washington, she did say that she thought about blowing up the White House, a poor choice of words, but words that were quickly taken out of context. She was expressing the frustration that had been building up inside of her since Trump was given the presidency. And that it had built up to the point where even that thought had flicked across her mind, (as thoughts do). It wasn't a call to any violent action, and immediately afterwards acknowledged that such action would not fix anything and that while good did not win the election, good would win in the end. Ultimately it was a call to action based on empowerment centered in love. It was delivered in a unapologetic in your face way, (hey, it was Madonna after all) but it wasn't a call to violence.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Victoria. I understand what you are saying about Madonna's words – I guess we all have thoughts like that sometimes! – but I still think it was the wrong thing to say. I wish she had more self control! But I appreciate her passion, and I have always loved her music.

      Delete
  23. Susan, thanks for saying so clearly and so eloquently what I would like to say myself. Beautiful!

    ReplyDelete
  24. Hi, Susan! I had a similar experience when I announced the Threads of Resistance call on Facebook. I run TAFA: The Textile and Fiber Art List (www.tafalist.com) and several of our members are involved in that show. Whew! The nastiest comments ever came out of our normally kind and gentle textile community. It took me by surprise because I posted about the Women's march on our blog and got no reaction. I had our banner on our Facebook page show one of Salley Mavor's dolls wearing a pussyhat for over a month and nobody reacted. But, when I posted the call for this show, I got the same types of comments that you did. I responded a couple of times and then decided not to engage.

    I grew up under a military dictatorship in Brazil as a missionary kid (1962-1980) and know what the face of authoritarianism looks like. I never expected to see it in this country. When the election results came in, I fell flat on my face and was in a daze for about a month. Then, I woke up and realized that he won because I, and people like me, did nothing. I haven't been involved in any civic actions for years and I think many of us have become complacent. Well, I guess we have had a rude awakening!

    I have to say that those of us who are against Trump are behaving just as badly as Trump supporters. I am so weary of all the name calling and hate that I see spewing out of both sides. Yeah, I can't believe people can find anything good about that man, but that doesn't mean that they don't have legitimate criticisms of concerns about the Democratic party. There are many things that I haven't agreed with during Obama's presidency or with Hillary's campaign. We have many social and economic problems to deal with and many of the strategies that have been used are not working. But, Trump is not the solution to them. Ugh. At any rate, I think all of us need to stick to the issues and look at having civil debates on how to fix these problems and call out personal attacks whenever we see them.

    My wake-up call has led me to become more engaged in my local community (Kentucky, in the thick of the battle ground!) and I started a new initiative where creative actions are used to encourage critical thinking and self awareness. It's called "Common Ground: Creatives in Action". The Threads of Resistance show is an example of a creative action. We have a Facebook group and are in the brainstorming phase and it's been fascinating. Quite a few people from other countries have joined. In fact, this post was shared by one of our members in our group. :)

    All are welcome to participate:
    https://www.facebook.com/groups/CommonGroundCreativesInAction/

    We are not alone and it has been so encouraging to see the majority in this country stand up for justice!

    ReplyDelete
  25. Thanks for speaking out----I am not going to keep my mouth shut either...You go...art is sometimes about pain isn't it.....

    ReplyDelete
  26. Thank you for your work and for this post. As I watch from the UK, I am horrified and worried. The UK is in no better a position, although the demagoguery is less obvious. The most powerful art has always addressed the bigger issues of life, please keep going.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Susan, more power to you and all of us for speaking your mind in a considered, thoughtful manner. You are an artist and a citizen and you have ad much right as anyone to voice your opinion. That's especially important now. I'm glad you responded to those who would have us quiet down. We won't.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Trump is only a symptom of what has gone wrong in this country. Please stop to consider that there are many different perspectives and part of the reason we are in this situation is because the people in this country who are truly intolerant can't see their own intolerance. As a Bible believing Christian I have seen my rights to peacefully live out my faith increasingly disappear under the banner of tolerance. When both sides are willing to let people live their lives freely without trying to destroy those they disagree with - then we will have tolerance. But as long as one side (whichever side) is declaring that there is no place for a particular viewpoint in the marketplace, that is not the freedom we are "guaranteed" in our Constitution. And yes I am posting this anonymously because I live in the state where a 70ish year old owner of a florist shop has been successfully sued out of everything except her home just because she was unable to reconcile her Christian beliefs with being forced to use her artistic talents to create floral arrangements for a gay wedding. Note that she had previously sold flowers to the man who sued her for years and considered him a friend, she just didn't want to be a part of celebrating his marriage to another man. So please remember that true tolerance means tolerance for everyone and coercing someone against their deeply held beliefs (which happen to go back millennia) just because you disagree with them is also intolerant.

    I guess all I'm asking is that both sides learn that we can live together peacefully only if we are willing to extend grace to each other in all areas where we disagree and rejoice with each other the many areas of life where we can find common ground.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Anonymous,
      Yes, there is so much common ground, if only we will listen to each other, and communicate without insults and threats. I appreciate you taking the time to express your thoughts. I can see both sides in the case of this florist. But … what if this woman owned apartments, instead of a floral shop, and refused to rent to a gay couple, or to African-Americans, or to Muslims? What if a LOT of people who owned apartments refused this? Here's where it gets legally sticky to me. Sometimes I wonder if we'd be better off if our political representatives had to go through mediation/arbitration, instead of our political process!

      Delete
    2. I guess my question back would be regarding the fashion designers who have said they refuse to sell their creations to Melania Trump because they believe that could be construed as endorsing her husband's beliefs - doesn't the florist have the same right and concern that providing custom floral arrangements for a gay wedding will be seen as endorsing an action she disagrees with? I believe our Constitution gives both the fashion designer and the florist the same right to refuse to have their artistic talents be used in a way that could be seen as an endorsement of actions they believe are wrong. In this case, it wasn't that the customer identified as gay that was the problem as evidenced by the fact that she had sold the man flowers for years, she just didn't want to be seen as endorsing behavior her faith told her was wrong.

      I guess to me the above dilemma is why I felt I had to respond to this post. I fully support the right of people to protest. But please, while protesting, could there be an acknowledgement that just because someone doesn't agree with you on all the above issues, it doesn't make them the enemy.

      I took a class from you last year that was fantastic and I think your work is amazing. It just saddens me to my core that because I am a Christian and take my faith seriously, I now feel unwelcome in a community I hoped I belonged to. It isn't Trump that is the problem (I didn't even vote for him), it is that there seem to be a whole lot of issues on which the quilt art community only allows one viewpoint to be held and I cannot hold some of those views and be true to my faith.

      Delete
    3. Dear Anonymous,
      To be clear: I never said that people were my enemy if they had views different from mine. I said that there is common ground. Viewing others as the enemy is pointless if we want to find that common ground.

      I disagree that "the quilt art community only allows one viewpoint to be held." This particular exhibition is a protest against Trump's actions and policies. That doesn't mean that another group of artists couldn't have their own exhibition where they celebrate those actions and policies. If this is something you feel strongly about, I encourage you to do this. It is obvious that you are upset, and making art can be very cathartic.

      I think part of what you might be responding to is that, in my experience, the majority of artists – creative writers, musicians, actors, and visual artists – are liberal. I think we will see a lot of protest art and music coming out of this era, just as America did in the 1960s, another time of tremendous social change.

      “Feeling unwelcome in a community I hoped to belong to" is a thing many groups in America – refugees, Muslims, Jews, immigrants – can identify with these days! I myself often feel unwelcome in my community, too, as I have mostly liberal viewpoints, and the area where I live is mostly conservative.

      Many Christians I know are accepting of gay marriage, have progressive viewpoints on social issues, and are deeply disturbed by the president’s policies and actions, so it seems odd to me that you say you "cannot hold some of those views and be true to my faith." I think what you mean is that you can't be true to your ideology.

      Lastly, I encourage you to use your name, and not remain anonymous. If you'd like to continue this conversation privately, you can always e-mail me directly.

      Delete
  29. Please continue to express yourself. I chose to read your blog. Real patriots understand that the US was formed through revolution not blindly following the monarchy. Discussion helps promote understanding and if I cannot hear your voice I can't listen to another point of view.

    I enjoy your art and message.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Susan, Thank you for standing up, speaking out, taking the flak. So sorry that people think trolling is acceptable, even honorable. Your courage and your art are an inspiration! Mary

    ReplyDelete
  31. Just for today and for tonight. .. I will say I love who you are Susan Brubaker Knapp. Your open heart and kindness is beautiful your willingness to be brave admirable and your education and knowledge is a joy. Keep listening to your heart, that is the right path....the path that values others and embodies joy and creativity. I love your style, your values and hearing about your joys. Just keep bringing Susan and you can't go wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  32. I continue to hear so many speak about being afraid. What is it that you fear?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Many children born in the U.S. to illegal Mexican immigrants fear their parents will be deported. Many women fear they will lose affordable health services like pap smears and birth control they now receive through Planned Parenthood. Many people fear losing the benefits they receive through the Affordable Care Act. Many people fear that the president's immigration policy and harsh language about Muslims will create hatred and increase terrorism. Many in the LGBT community fear discrimination. Many fear the influence of the "alt-right" and Neo Nazis in the white house. Many are afraid that environmental protections will be loosened, that the environment will be damaged, that data about climate change will be destroyed, that our water and air will be more polluted. Many fear that the press – one of the primary ways corruption is rooted out – is being degraded by the president's words. Many fear that the president is unstable, and that he will react too quickly and push the button on nuclear weapons. I could go on and on and on... What do I fear most? I fear that if we don't find ways to start talking, finding common ground, and compromising, we will have our second American Civil War.

      Delete
  33. Thank you for this well thought post. I have been blocked by any number of people for speaking my mind about these issues. Like you, I woke up to the realization if I don't speak out, I am part of the problem. We have to 'discuss' in order to find common ground. Art has always had people use it to show their political point of view. Thank you for sharing your art with us.

    ReplyDelete

I love it when you leave comments… Otherwise I feel like I'm just talking to myself! If you have time to write, please let me know what you think.